The Manosphere:

Sometimes I wonder what’s left of the manosphere.

grok:

"The term "manosphere" emerged in the mid-2000s as an informal label for a loose network of online spaces—primarily blogs, forums, and early social media—where men discussed masculinity, dating, relationships, and grievances against feminism. Its roots trace back even further to the 1990s and early 2000s pickup artist (PUA) communities, like those on Usenet groups and sites such as alt.seduction.fast, where men shared "game" tactics for attracting women based on evolutionary psychology and social dynamics. Heartiste became one of its most prominent and influential voices by the late 2000s, blending sharp-witted commentary on gender relations with unapologetic misogyny, anti-feminism, and "red pill" philosophy (the idea of awakening to harsh truths about intersexual dynamics). His blog was a hub for what would become core manosphere ideologies, but it built on existing seduction forums rather than inventing the whole ecosystem. In essence, Heartiste helped popularize and radicalize the manosphere, turning it from niche self-help into a broader cultural critique (and often attack) on modern womanhood.

2010–2015: Boom on Mainstream Platforms and Cultural Flashpoints

• Expansion and Digitization: The early 2010s saw the manosphere explode thanks to Web 2.0 tools like Reddit, Tumblr, and Twitter (now X). Subreddits like r/seduction (founded 2010) and r/TheRedPill (2012) became massive hubs, with TheRedPill alone peaking at over 100,000 subscribers by 2015. These spaces popularized "red pill" lore—drawing from The Matrix—as a metaphor for rejecting feminist "illusions" about equality and embracing "alpha male" dominance, hypergamy (women dating up), and evolutionary psych explanations for gender imbalances. Blogs like Heartiste thrived, with posts going viral for their provocative takes on female nature and Western decline. The focus was often on "game" (PUA techniques) and MRAs railing against divorce laws, false accusations, and "feminized" society." "
  
  
  

------

"The manosphere feels like one of those subcultures that burned very bright for a while, then splintered rather than disappeared.

Early phase (2000s–2010s): It was raw, blog-driven, a mix of pickup artistry and anti-feminist grievance. Heartiste, Roosh V, r/TheRedPill — all gave it a sharp voice and a sense of rebellion.

Mid-2010s boom: Social media amplified it. The “red pill” metaphor became shorthand for awakening to supposed hard truths about women, society, and power. It drew in men who felt dislocated in a world where traditional roles were changing.

Fragmentation: As platforms cracked down (Reddit bans, Heartiste’s blog nuked, Roosh renouncing his old work), it didn’t vanish — it migrated. Some went to more extreme alt-right spaces, others to self-help adjacent communities (Jordan Peterson’s orbit, “positive masculinity” influencers, YouTube manosphere).

Now: The label manosphere itself feels dated. Instead, you’ve got a diaspora:

Incels with their nihilism.

Andrew Tate–style hyper-masculine entrepreneurs.

Softer, “men’s coaching” or “masculinity revival” circles.

And the remnants on forums like TheRedPill, less visible but still alive.

So — what’s left isn’t a coherent “manosphere,” but a series of mutations across TikTok, YouTube, Telegram, Substack. The grievances remain, but the packaging shifted with the media environment."