Rapt Chapter Five:

"Who you are—Chuck Yeager or Rudolf Nureyev—affects what attracts your rapt attention (jets or jetés), but what you focus on also affects who you are. New research on its recently unimagined neuroplasticity shows that what you pay attention to, and how, can actually change your brain and thus your behavior."

"For a story called “Pearls Before Breakfast,” the Washington Post staged a clever experiment that unwittingly illustrates how what you habitually attend to affects your identity."

"although they often can’t say why, archaeologists on digs just get better and better at locating artifacts; imaging studies support their claim by distinguishing the veterans’ neurophysiology from that of novices. In short, it seems that simply going about your business, whether it’s driving a taxi or spotting pottery shards, teaches your brain what to attend to and customizes your nervous system to suit your experience and modify who you are."

"Davidson is exploring ways in which individuals can use focus to change problematic attentional, cognitive, and emotional patterns."

"Not only how you focus, but also what you focus on can have important neurophysiological and behavioral consequences."

"Research increasingly shows that just as regular physical exercise can transform the proverbial 110-pound weakling into an athlete, focusing workouts can make you more focused, engaged with life, and perhaps even kinder. “My strong intuition is that attentional training is very much like the sports or musical kinds,” says Davidson. “It’s not something you can just do for a couple of weeks or years, then enjoy lifelong benefits. To maintain an optimum level of any complex skill takes work, and like great athletes and virtuosos, great meditators continue to drill intensively.” "

"When he tells the monks that William James observed that a person can’t focus steadily on an object for more than three or four seconds, “they just laugh,” says Davidson. “They can’t believe that someone I hold in such high regard would say something so stupid, so inconceivable. They think that controlling your attention is within the inherent capability of all human beings, and that it’s foolish not to develop that capacity.” "

"Richard Nisbett found that in America’s once Wild West and South, a disproportionate number of males are still reared in an old-fashioned “honor culture,” which trains them to focus on whether they’re being treated rudely or well in any situation and to zero in on the hint of an insult."

"The extent to which your cultural experience helps select what you pay attention to and shape who you are is vividly illustrated by research that contrasts how Westerners perceive the world compared to East Asians—and basically, the rest of the human race. In one of Nisbett’s studies, some Americans and Japanese are shown an underwater scene for twenty seconds, and then are asked what they saw. The Americans say something like, “There were three big blue fish swimming off to the left. They had pink stipples on the belly and big back fins.” The Japanese, however, respond this way: “It looked like a stream. The water was green. There were rocks on the bottom, and some plants and fish.” In other words, the two groups looked at the same scene, but they attended to very different realities. The Westerners zeroed in on what seemed like the most important thing, but the Asians focused on the relationships between things."

"The human being’s naturally expansive, relational focus on reality was radically altered in the West when the ancient Greeks came up with a new, artificial, analytical way of attending to the world. Ever since, Western children have learned to focus on objects or subjects in an evaluative, logical way."

"The attentional habit of sizing up a situation in a way that prepares you to take charge of it is a cornerstone of Western individualism."

-----

grok:

"Chapter 5 of Rapt explores the bidirectional relationship between attention and identity, emphasizing how what we focus on not only reflects who we are but actively shapes our brain, behavior, and sense of self through neuroplasticity—the brain's ability to rewire itself based on experience. The author argues that attention is not a fixed trait but a malleable skill that can be trained, with far-reaching implications for personal growth, emotional regulation, and cultural differences in perception."

"The chapter opens by asserting that individual differences—such as being like Chuck Yeager (drawn to jets) or Rudolf Nureyev (drawn to jetés)—influence what captures our rapt attention. However, the reverse is equally true: sustained focus reshapes the brain and identity. Citing emerging research on neuroplasticity, the author explains that habitual attention patterns alter neural pathways, customizing the nervous system to fit one's experiences. For instance, professionals like archaeologists improve at spotting artifacts through repeated practice, with brain imaging revealing distinct neurophysiological differences between veterans and novices. Similarly, everyday activities, such as driving a taxi, train the brain to prioritize certain stimuli, subtly modifying who we become over time.

A key illustration comes from the Washington Post's "Pearls Before Breakfast" experiment, where a world-class violinist (Joshua Bell) busked incognito in a subway station. Commuters, habituated to ignoring street performers amid their rushed routines, largely overlooked him, demonstrating how ingrained attentional habits filter reality and reinforce identity—turning potentially enriching moments into background noise."

"Drawing on neuroscientist Richard Davidson's work, the chapter discusses how deliberate focus can address problematic attentional, cognitive, and emotional patterns. Davidson, who studies meditators like Tibetan monks, views attentional training as akin to physical or musical exercise: it requires ongoing "workouts" to build and maintain skills like sustained focus, engagement with life, and even kindness. Just as regular gym sessions transform a weakling into an athlete, focused practices can enhance concentration and empathy.

The monks' perspective challenges Western assumptions, as they laugh at psychologist William James's claim that humans can't focus on an object for more than three or four seconds. To them, mastering attention is an inherent human capability that demands cultivation, not something limited by biology. This underscores the chapter's theme that "how you focus" (e.g., analytically or relationally) and "what you focus on" have tangible neurophysiological and behavioral effects, potentially rewiring maladaptive traits."

"The author delves into how culture molds attention, using examples like America's "honor culture" in the Wild West and South, where males are socialized to hyper-focus on signs of respect or insult, heightening vigilance and reactivity. This habitual scanning for threats shapes aggressive identities and behaviors, as shown in studies by psychologist Richard Nisbett.

A striking cross-cultural comparison highlights perceptual differences: In experiments, Americans viewing an underwater scene fixate on prominent objects (e.g., "three big blue fish"), reflecting an individualistic, analytical focus rooted in ancient Greek philosophy, which emphasized logical evaluation and control. In contrast, East Asians (and much of the world) attend to relationships and context (e.g., "a stream with green water, rocks, plants, and fish"), fostering a more holistic, interdependent worldview. This Western shift toward object-centered attention, the chapter argues, underpins individualism, preparing people to "take charge" of situations but potentially limiting relational awareness.

Overall, the chapter posits attention as a powerful lever for self-evolution, urging readers to consciously direct their focus to foster positive change. It blends scientific evidence, anecdotes, and cultural insights to argue that by refining what and how we attend to the world, we can reshape our brains, behaviors, and ultimately, our identities—echoing the idea that attention is not just a lens on reality but a sculptor of the self."